When I accepted the chili cook off challenge – I knew I wanted to make something different.
Normally – I just throw a whole bunch of beans in a pot (much to Mike’s dismay, chickpeas are usually included) – throw in some quinoa, and call it a day.
It’s delicious.
But I’ve learned – not crowd pleasing.
(or should I say – not crowd pleasing, if you asked Mike – and I think he’s a good judge of the “norm” – I fall in to “crazy food blogger” category – so I can’t be trusted
)
So when I found this recipe on All Recipes – I knew it needed to be my chili base!
But of course – I had to make some of my own changes!
![]()
Ingredients:
- 2 medium sized Butternut Squash
- 2 cans of Kidney Beans
- (I used dark red & light red)
- 1 can of Great Northern Beans
- 1 can of White Hominy
- (I used half the can picture – I couldn’t find a normal can – just that crazy super sized one)
- 1 can of Petite Diced Tomatoes with Green Chilies
- 2 cans of Tomato Sauce
- (I had originally planned on 1 can of Tomato Sauce and 1 can of Tomato Paste – but you know me – I like to change things on the fly!)
- 1/2 of a jar of Banana Peppers
- 2 medium white onions (not pictured here)
- Minced Garlic (not pictured here)
- (I always cheat and use the pre-minced garlic cloves that come in the jar)
- Optional: Butter Beans
- (I was going to use them, and decided not to at the last second!)
Step 1: Chop 1 Butternut Squash (leaving the other for later) – into cubes, salt heavily with sea salt, and roast in the oven for 45 minutes, at 375.
![]()
Step 2: Chop the 2 onions to desired size, and start cooking those over medium heat
![]()
Step 3: Chop the other Butternut Squash into cubes (should take you about 10 minutes)
Step 4: Add as much garlic (I used 4 heaping spoonfuls) and ALL canned ingredients to the onion mixture
Step 5: Add the chopped butternut squash (just the one – remember – the other squash is cubed and roasting in the oven
) to the onion/garlic/canned mixture
![]()
Step 6: Add spices. I didn’t measure, seeing as I’m not physically capable of doing so – but I used a very fair amount of cumin, chili power and garlic salt – and just a sprinkle or two of crushed red pepper
![]()
![]()
Step 7: (VEGETARIANS LOOK AWAY!) Once the pot is squared away – start browning 1lb of lean ground turkey
![]()
Step 8: After the meat is browned – add it to the pot – give it all a good stir – and then bring it to a boil. Once it’s boiling, reduce heat and let it simmer for another 20 minutes.
![]()
Step 9: Right around then – the timer for the roasted squash should be going off! Remove the amazingly delicious looking squash from the oven (and turn off that annoying buzzer!)
![]()
Step 10: Add the roasted butternut squash to the mix!
![]()
Step 11: Let it sit overnight so all the flavors really meld, and then bring it in to your chili cook off at work – and WIN THE PEOPLE’S CHOICE AWARD!
That’s right – this chili won me the People’s Choice Award – best out 20!
The prize? 2 gift cards, a Starbucks mug, and awesome trophy…
…but most importantly? Bragging rights.


16 Comments so far
Leave a comment
yayyy! Congrats on the win! I’ve made a chili like this before (sans the meat) and it was fantastic! Next time, I plan to toss some turkey into Josh’s bowl. Hope you’re doing well <3
[Reply]
By Erica on 10.26.10 9:25 am | Permalink
Allison,
That chili looks super good. I’ll have to make it sometime. Or you can always make it for me : ) Lets get together soon and cook. See you soon!
[Reply]
By Caroline on 10.26.10 9:30 am | Permalink
you’re awesome!! and i have that same starbucks mug… i mean, we’re basically twins!
[Reply]
By susan (stepping off the coaster) on 10.26.10 10:55 am | Permalink
Yay congratulations! I think added roasted squash to anything would make it prize-worthy!
[Reply]
By Caitlin on 10.26.10 11:07 am | Permalink
I am not at all suprised this won the people’s choice award- sounds DELISH!!
[Reply]
By Heather @ Side of Sneakers on 10.26.10 1:16 pm | Permalink
Great recipe! Im going to make it for the fam I cook for this week!
[Reply]
By The Healthy Hostess on 10.26.10 2:41 pm | Permalink
bnut squash?? banana peppers? i’m in!!! definitely going to try this sometime this winter!
[Reply]
By natalie (the sweets life) on 10.26.10 4:00 pm | Permalink
Nice work – looks delicious!
Laura
[Reply]
By sweetersalt on 10.26.10 4:50 pm | Permalink
Hooray for the win!
When I was making my lunch today, I made a ground chicken bolognese with pumpkin – both Hannah and Tony happened to be walking in the kitchen at the exact moment I was putting the canned pumpkin in – I think they both threw up in their mouth a little – I didn’t care – I had it over spaghetti squash for my lunch and it was delicious!
Of course, if I copied your recipe, I’ll leave out the onions!
p.s. I’ve never found smaller cans of hominy either – luckily they keep well in the fridge!
[Reply]
By Biz on 10.26.10 5:54 pm | Permalink
You are the CHAMPION! I love the trophy. Display it proudly
[Reply]
By Amanda on 10.26.10 5:56 pm | Permalink
Yay that looks so delicious! Congrats on the big win.
[Reply]
By Paige on 10.26.10 6:03 pm | Permalink
great looking recipe! I have been craving chili for weeks now!
[Reply]
By Balanced Healthy Life on 10.26.10 6:59 pm | Permalink
way to go crazy food blogger
[Reply]
By RunToTheFinish on 10.28.10 2:48 pm | Permalink
[...] Butternut Squash Turkey Chili *AWARD WINNING* [...]
By Recipe Tab Makeover | Green Dog Wine on 01.11.11 10:42 am | Permalink
[...] Remember when I made the most crowd-pleasin’ chili around and won some sweet prizes for it? [...]
By Tucky’s | Green Dog Wine on 01.17.11 1:20 pm | Permalink
I made this over the weekend and it is delicious! It turns out to be so much for just one person so I gave half to my parents. I heard it was the best chili they have ever eaten. I’ve now passed the recipe and your website to several people at my office. I also LOVE the artichoke reuben! Great job!
[Reply]
By Annie on 01.18.11 4:43 pm | Permalink
Leave a comment